Stovall v. Denno

388 U.S. 293 (1967)

Purchase the Printed Copy at bsmsphd.com

Nature of the Case

To access this section all you need to do is click here and register.

Facts

A Dr. and his wife were attacked in their own home. The Dr. was stabbed to death in the kitchen of his home. The Dr.'s wife, also a Dr. followed her husband into the kitchen and jumped at the assailant. Stovall (D) knocked her to the floor and stabbed her 11 times. The police found a shirt on the kitchen floor and keys in a pocket, which they traced to D. D, was arrested and an arraignment was immediately held but was postponed until D could retain counsel. The wife was hospitalized for major surgery to save her life. D got counsel, and the police immediately brought D to the hospital to have the wife identify him. She did by visual and voice. At trial, she identified D again. D got the death penalty. Various lower appeals were taken with a reversal and then an affirmation of the trial judge's ruling regarding the admissibility of the hospital identification; D was the only black man present. The issue before the Court was whether due process had been violated.