State v. Abbott

36 N.J. 63, 174 A.2d 881 (1961)

Purchase the Printed Copy at bsmsphd.com

Nature of the Case

To access this section all you need to do is click here and register.

Facts

D shared a common driveway with his neighbors, Michael and Mary Scarano. The Scaranos engaged a contractor to pave their portion. D obtained some asphalt from the contractor and made a doorstop to keep his garage door from swinging onto the Scaranos' property. Nicholas Scarano, the son, objected to Ds innovation. After some words between them, a fist fight ensued. D landed the first punch, and Michael Scarano came at D with a hatchet. Mary Scarano followed, armed with a carving knife and large fork. All of the Scaranos were hit by the hatchet. Nicholas received severe head injuries. D claimed a laceration. D admitted he wrested the hatchet from Michael but denied he wielded it at all. D insisted that the Scaranos were injured during a common struggle for the instrument. D was separately indicted for atrocious assault and battery upon each of the Scaranos. There was a common trial of these indictments. The jury acquitted D of the charges relating to Michael and Mary, but found him guilty as to Nicholas. D appealed.