Smith v. Superior Court (Abbott Ford

151 Cal.App.3d 491 (1984)

Facts

Smith (P) was hurt when a wheel from another vehicle crashed through her windshield. P sued Abbot Ford (D), the company responsible for the wheel that caused her injuries. P and D agreed that D would retain custody of the wheel. However, D misplaced the wheel after delivery. P wanted to change her complaint to include the intentional spoliation of the evidence. The trial court held that no cause of action existed and sustained D's demurrer. P petitioned for a writ of mandate overturning the trial court.