Saxby v. Southern Land Co. Ct. Of App. Of Va., L

09 Va. 196, 63 S.E. 423 (1909)

Purchase the Printed Copy at bsmsphd.com

Nature of the Case

To access this section all you need to do is click here and register.

Facts

Southern (D) represented to Saxby (P) that he owned Winslow farm and that it could not be purchased for less than $8,000. D did not own the farm but had only an option to purchase it. The real owners were anxious to sell and would have sold it for $4,000. P also claims that D represented the farm to contain at least 150 acres of pine timber, of which about 20 acres had been burned over; whereas, there was about 120 acres in timber, of which about 60 acres had been burned over. P also alleged that D stated the timber, when cut into cordwood, would readily sell at the local stations on the railroad for $4.00 per cord; whereas, it could be sold only for a much smaller price; and that the land was specially adapted to potato culture, and would by the use of fertilizer yield one hundred bushels of potatoes to the acre; whereas, by actual experiment the land failed to produce anything like that yield by the use of fertilizers. P sued for misrepresentation. D's demurrer was sustained; D's statement was opinion and not subject to suit. P appealed.