Raytheon filed a suit and alleged that the illegal conduct of R.C.A. completely destroyed the profitable interstate and foreign commerce of its tube business. Raytheon alleged that by 1928, its business with a value in excess of three million dollars was now worthless. The allegations and evidence of the amount of profits was used to establish goodwill and a method on which to recover a return of capital. The suit was ended in a compromise settlement. The IRS got involved and said that this settlement was taxable as income. Raytheon disagreed and appealed that decision.