People v. Moran

246 N.Y. 100, 158 N.E. 35 (1927)

Purchase the Printed Copy at bsmsphd.com

Nature of the Case

To access this section all you need to do is click here and register.

Facts

D and four companions were driving in a car when police stopped them. The driver of the car obeyed the police commands, but D didn't, and D shot both officers dead. D fled and hid but surrendered a few days later. The trial judge left the case to the jury upon the single theory of homicide by one engaged in the commission of a felony. The judge refused to submit the other degrees of homicide to the jury other than murder in the first degree. The judge indicated that if D after shooting the first officer shot the second in an effort to escape, this was homicide while engaged in the commission of a felony and so it was murder in the first degree, irrespective of intent. D was convicted and appealed.