People v. Ligouri

284 N.Y. 309, 31 N.E.2d 37 (1940)

Facts

Ligouri (D) claimed that he had been assaulted by Cosaluzzo. Cosaluzzo drew a gun and pointed it at D. D stood his ground, drew a pistol, and killed Cosaluzzo. The trial court judge instructed the jury that self-defense was available only if D failed to retreat because he would have been in imminent danger had he done so. D was convicted of murder. D appealed.