New York Bronze Powder Co. v. Benjamin Acquisition Corp

716 A.2d 230 (1998)

Purchase the Printed Copy at bsmsphd.com

Nature of the Case

To access this section all you need to do is click here and register.

Facts

New York Bronze (P) entered into an agreement with Benjamin Acquisition Corp. (D) for D to purchase from P assets of the business then known as Benjamin Rich Company. The price was to be $4.5 million with assumption of certain Rich liabilities. Shortly before closing, D expressed concern over the valuation of certain assets. A modification of the purchase agreement was reached with $350,000 of the purchase price to be deferred and taken in a nonnegotiable note to P for $350,000. Under that agreement, D undertook to prepare a balance sheet to be delivered to P no later than June 14, 1990, that if the audited balance sheet reflected a net worth of less than $4.5 million, D was entitled to a dollar for dollar credit on the $350,000 deferred purchase price. The deal was closed under the modified agreement, but the accounting firm never completed its audit. D never made nor tendered any cash payment on the note. P sued D for nonpayment on the note and breach of the modified asset purchase agreement. P got the verdict and D appealed. The Court of Special Appeals held that the italicized portion of the note (page 422 Calamari 3rd) created a condition, the nonoccurrence of which extinguished D's obligation to pay the $350,000 or any part thereof; as P had not surrendered the note they were not entitled to payment. P then appealed.