Mcneil v. Wisconsin

501 U.S. 171 (1991)

Purchase the Printed Copy at bsmsphd.com

Nature of the Case

To access this section all you need to do is click here and register.

Facts

McNeil (D) was arrested in Nebraska on a warrant for armed robbery in Wisconsin. Milwaukee sheriffs arrived shortly thereafter and advised him of his Miranda rights. D refused to answer any questions but did not request an attorney. D was brought back to Wisconsin and was arraigned. A public defender was appointed. Later that evening detective Butts visited D in jail. Butts was interested in murder, attempted murder, and an armed burglary in Caledonia. D was a suspect. Butts advised D of his Miranda rights and D signed a form waiving them. D claimed he had not been involved in the Caledonia crimes. Butts returned two days later and advised D of his Miranda rights again; D initialed the forms. D then admitted he had been involved in the Caledonia crimes and implicated two other men. The statement was typed and given to D for review; he signed every page and initialed each reference to himself. After questioning the other alleged accomplices, Butts returned to D again and once again gave him Miranda warnings got the signature on them and the waiver form. D then acknowledged that he had lied about the involvement of others to minimize his own role. A statement was made again, recorded again, signed again, and initialed again. D was convicted but appealed on the issue of whether his Sixth Amendment right had been invoked.