Evan v. State

28 P.3d 498 (2001)

Purchase the Printed Copy at bsmsphd.com

Nature of the Case

To access this section all you need to do is click here and register.

Facts

Adriana was four-years-old at the time of the murders. She witnessed them and testified at trial. At trial, the prosecutor first questioned her about her family and the difference between truth and lies and the need, to tell the truth. She said that two men entered the apartment and she referred to them as Scary Eyes and Little Ray. She said the men shot the two male victims and then shot the two women, one who was in the bathroom and the other in a bedroom. She could not remember how many times the two women were shot or which one of the two men fired the shots. She did not see how many men left the apartment. Afterward her mother called the apartment, and she told her that Scotti was dead. She said she did not know Scary Eyes, but she had seen Little Ray before. Her mother testified that she had referred to Evans (D) as Little Ray in the past. She was six when she testified and had already testified at a preliminary hearing, a grand jury hearing, and a federal sentencing hearing, by her mother, neighbors, detectives, a child psychologist, and the media. She was taped by reporters telling the same story. D was convicted and appealed.