Crook v. Cowan

64 N.C. 743 (1870)

Purchase the Printed Copy at bsmsphd.com

Nature of the Case

To access this section all you need to do is click here and register.

Facts

Cowan (D) wanted to buy two carpets as per the specification of a letter written to Crook (P). The letter gave an express set of instructions to P and only required P to notify D if he wanted payment by terms different from the letter. D did not receive a reply to his first letter and sent a follow-up to determine if P was even interested in the deal. Then D received a reply that the carpets had already been delivered. D then wrote another letter expressing surprise that the carpets were there especially since his first letter was never acknowledged by P. P sued. The trial court declined to give certain jury instructions about the fact that because P never acknowledged the order, D was discharged from the contract. D also wanted an instruction that there was no contract. The verdict went to P and D appealed.