Cain v. Hearst Corporation

878 S.W.2d 577 (1994)

Purchase the Printed Copy at bsmsphd.com

Nature of the Case

To access this section all you need to do is click here and register.

Facts

Cain (P) is a prison inmate serving a life sentence for murder. P sued Hearst (D) claiming that a newspaper article invaded his privacy by placing him in a false light. The article referred to P as a burglar, thief, pimp, and killer. D printed that P is believed to have killed as many as eight people; P killed one of his lawyers in 1973 and married the lawyer's widow a few months later; P killed a 67-year-old man in 1977; in 1983 he 'bought' a prostitute from a friend to help finance his activities; P persuaded the prostitute to marry a trailer park owner named Anderson, so that P could kill Anderson and share the prostitute's inheritance from Anderson; when the prostitute balked, P threatened to kill her 5-year-old daughter and 'deliver her daughter's head in a wastepaper basket'; the prostitute married Anderson 3 days later, and on January 5, 1985, P killed Anderson. P's sole complaint is that the article printed false information that he was a member of the 'Dixie Mafia' and that he had killed as many as eight people. P asserted that these statements put him in a false light with the public. Suit was filed in state court one and one-half years after the article was published. D removed the case to federal court, and the court granted D's motion for dismissal on the grounds that P's action lies in libel, and held that the one-year limitations period expired before P brought the suit. P appealed, and the court certified questions.