Brantley v. Wilson

2006 WL 436121 (2006)

Purchase the Printed Copy at bsmsphd.com

Nature of the Case

To access this section all you need to do is click here and register.

Facts

D owns the parcel of real property that is approximately 37 acres. P contacted D by telephone to determine whether the Property was for sale, and if so, at what price. D informed P that the property was for sale, and was priced at $ 10,000 per acre, or $ 370,000 for the parcel. P and D began communicating about the Property, exclusively by e-mail, beginning on February 7, 2005. In the emails, P and D agreed to a purchase price of $370,000, in cash at the time of closing, with closing costs to be split 50/50. No closing date was set. P stated that he would not have trouble obtaining financing. P requested a survey of the property. The parties did not discuss a deposit of earnest money in connection with the sale. The parties did not discuss whether P would be taking title to the Property in fee simple absolute, or whether Ds would retain the mineral interests. On February 18, 2005, P signed a real estate contract prepared by their attorney and forwarded it to Wilson. D has not signed this contract. On February 20, 2005, D notified P that she was not willing to sell the Property for $10,000 per acre. P filed suit for specific performance and placed a lis pendens against the Property on May 4, 2005. D contends that the parties never entered into a contract because certain elements essential to the formation of a contract are missing from their e-mails. Both parties moved for summary judgment.