International Brotherhood Of Teamsters v. Fleming Companie

975 P.2d 907 (1999)

Purchase the Printed Copy at bsmsphd.com

Nature of the Case

To access this section all you need to do is click here and register.

Facts

The Teamsters (P) owned sixty-five shares of Fleming Companies (D). In 1986, D instituted a shareholder rights plan with the term of the plan to expire in 1996. D adopted this plan as an anti-takeover method. P were critical of D's rights plan, seeing it as a means of entrenching the current board of directors in the event D became the target of a takeover. In 1996, P organized and introduced a nonbinding resolution for the annual shareholder meeting; it called for the D board to redeem the existing rights plan. The rights plan remained intact despite a majority shareholder vote in agreement with P to redeem it. P once again attempted reform and in 1997 put an amendment to vote to the company bylaws that required that any rights plans would need shareholder ratification. D refused to include that resolution in its 1997 proxy; the proposal was not a subject for shareholder action. P then brought an action in the Federal District Court for the Western District of Oklahoma. The trial court ruled that the plan D instituted effectively removed corporate authority regarding share marketability from the shareholders and vested it exclusively in the board of directors. P got the judgment and D appealed. D was forced to hold the vote, and the motion passed. The 10th Circuit submitted a certified question to the Oklahoma Supreme Court.